The Milburn Review: key questions to consider
Tuesday’s Milburn Review could be transformative for youth employment. Whether it is, will depend on the detail and how the Government responds. A lot has already been trailed, including a legal “opportunity guarantee”, a shift in spending from benefits to support and possible employer National Insurance cuts. The reported changes to benefits for under-25s will be closely scrutinised. If benefits for young people are reduced, it becomes even more important that good opportunities and effective support are available.
Two big questions, and what I’ll be looking for.
1) Will the proposed reforms create more opportunities and routes into good work for young people?
Much of the recent rise in the number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) has been driven by falling employment. Demand for young workers has weakened, particularly in sectors such as retail and hospitality that have traditionally provided entry points into the labour market. These challenges have been compounded by declines in ‘Saturday jobs’, work experience placements and apprenticeships, that help young people get a foothold in the labour market. Compared to other OECD countries, we also have far fewer vocational education routes into work.
The key question is whether the proposals would expand genuine routes into good work. How will the Review fit with the Government’s wider plans for growth and its measures affecting employers? How will recent reforms be built on to expand pathways into work? And how will employers be supported and challenged to recruit young people without prior experience, offer flexibility and adjustments where needed, and provide effective training?
2) Will young people get the support they need to access those opportunities?
The Youth Guarantee has expanded the support available for young people but we still spend far less on employment support compared to other countries. Our research shows that access isn’t simply about whether a service exists. Distrust, fear, stigma and poor service design can all prevent young people from engaging. Well-designed, good-quality employment support, on the other hand, means that young people are likely more to engage with it and that they’ll be better off in the long term.
The international evidence shows that work-first approaches that focus on support, rather than compliance and sanctions, are far more likely to lead to sustainable, long-term outcomes – improving employment outcomes for individuals and reducing the welfare bill. Investment in well-designed support is good for young people, the economy and the exchequer.
Young people also need support that is easy to find and navigate, and available when they need it. That’s not the case at the moment. Our research mapped around 80 targeted support mechanisms for just four groups of disadvantaged young people, illustrating how complex the landscape has become. And support often drops away once a young person leaves an education setting or starts work, despite transitions into employment being one of the periods when help may be most needed.
There will likely be an emphasis on the role of mayors and local partners in creating a more joined up system of support for young people – organising support around young people’s journeys, rather than around institutional boundaries. Sustainable improvements are more likely to come from strengthening local systems than from introducing isolated programmes.
The key question here is whether places are given sufficient powers and resources to create truly joined-up, effective support. The other is how local areas are supported to build the capacity, capability and partnerships needed to use those powers effectively. It’s no surprise, given the highly centralised nature of the system and constraints on budgets, that there is such variability in capacity at the local level. Supporting partners to understand and implement what works, and share learning, will be vital.
Any views expressed are those of the author and not necessarily those of the Institute as a whole.