Poor management is holding back the UK's recovery, warns new BIS report
11 Jul 2012
Poor management and leadership is holding back the UK's economic growth, according to a new report from the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills. It highlights the growing research evidence suggesting that the UK is lagging behind international competitors. Nearly three quarters of employers in England report a deficit of management and leadership skills, while 43% of managers regard their own line manager as ineffective.1
The report follows numerous high-profile management failures which have dominated the news since the start of the credit crunch and continue to make headlines in 2012. But the evidence shows that such incidents are only the tip of the iceberg, with the costs of ineffective management being felt much more widely across the economy.
Entitled Leadership & Management in the UK - The Key to Sustainable Growth, the report was produced by BIS in partnership with leading stakeholders. It provides a concise overview of the latest research evidence to help business advisers show employers why they may need to look again at their management and leadership capability.
The report sets out the policies put in place by the Government in England to address these critical skills gaps, such as the Growth Accelerator initiative, which provides tailored business packages to high growth businesses; the Growth and Innovation Fund which provides support to employers wanting to create sustainable skills solutions; and the Employer Ownership Pilot which provides funds to employers setting up their own training programmes. The report also includes policies put in place by the Scottish Government, the Welsh Assembly and the Northern Ireland Executive.
John Hayes MP, Minister of State for Further Education, Skills and Lifelong Learning, launched the report at a meeting of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Management on Tuesday evening.
‘Too many of our organisations, both private and public, are failing to achieve their full potential. Improving our leadership and management capability is fundamental to creating a culture where more organisations have the ambition, confidence, resilience and skills to respond to compete successfully, both nationally and globally.
‘Government is supporting this process by creating a framework for business growth and by providing specific support to those businesses with the most potential.
‘Employers have to be the driving force behind any improvements. The potential gains are clear: improved survival rates, better employee motivation and well-being, and increased profitability and performance.'
Welcoming the report, Ann Francke, CEO of the Chartered Management Institute, said:
‘This report provides compelling evidence that investing in management and leadership best practices improves business performance. Let's use this as a basis for convincing our customers - the UK's employers - that growing the number and quality of professional managers makes outstanding commercial sense. A timely side benefit of this is that professional managers are, by definition, ethical managers who have signed up to a code of conduct - and recent events remind us that putting ethics back into business has become an imperative for UK PLC.’
Peter Cheese, Chief Executive, Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development, said:
‘There are eight million people in the UK workforce with direct management responsibility for one or more people. This army of people managers has a huge impact on this country's productivity and global competitiveness - not to mention on individual and social wellbeing and resilience.
‘Leadership can no longer be about a few charismatic 'masters of the universe' at the top. There's a whole cadre of managers in the middle and on the front line who need to be equipped and inspired with the skills to lead and to win hearts and minds - from the very earliest stages of their careers. We can't as a nation afford to keep promoting people to management roles and assuming that these capabilities come naturally. We need a step change in the UK in how we develop and promote people management in every organisation, as this report so clearly highlights.’
Charles Elvin, CEO of the Institute of Leadership & Management, says:
‘This report confirms the importance of ensuring high levels of leadership and management skills at all levels in an organisation. This requires a culture of investing in leadership and management development to create an effective talent pipeline. It is important that business leaders equip employees with the skills they need for a better performing workforce in order to optimise organisational performance.’
Dr Penny Tamkin, Associate Director at the Institute for Employment Studies and one of the contributors to the report, comments:
‘Whatever business performance stone we turn, whether that be innovation, engagement, business survival or productivity, we find management and leadership beneath it. Its contribution is sometimes unclear and often complex and difficult, but that does not excuse our tendency to ignore it. This paper makes that ignorance harder to sustain and gives some helpful pointers for organisations to improve their leadership and management capability.’
Harriet Fitzgerald / Shona Mathew
Telephone: 0207 010 0828 / 0207 010 0884
NOTES TO EDITORS
1. The CIPD Annual Survey Report 2012 showed that 72% of organisations in England reported a deficit of management and leadership skills. 43% of managers rate their own line manager as ineffective according to a survey of 4,496 managers, in The Business Benefits of Management and Leadership Development, CMI, February 2012.
- The BIS evidence report, Leadership & Management in the UK - The Key to Sustainable Growth, will be published on the BIS website, www.bis.gov.uk
- The membership of the Leadership & Management Network Group includes Acas, CIPD, CMI, IES and ILM, who supported the development of the report, plus others including the CBI, TUC, Advanced Institute of Management (AIM) Research, the British Quality Foundation, the Institute of Directors, Business in the Community, and agencies including the UK Commission for Employment and Skills, the Skills Funding Agency, and sector skills councils.
- CMI is the only chartered professional body dedicated to raising standards of management and leadership across all sectors of UK commerce and industry. By setting minimum professional standards - built into our qualifications, membership criteria and learning resources - we recognise individual capability and give employers confidence in their managers' performance. As a membership organisation, CMI has also been providing forward-thinking advice and support to individuals and businesses, for more than 50 years. As the only organisation to offer qualifications from Level 2 (GCSE) to Level 8 (PhD), CMI is committed to equipping individuals with the skills and knowledge to be exceptional managers and leaders. Qualifications and accreditations such as Chartered Manager, combined with products such as CMI's Continuous Professional Development scheme and the online support resource, ManagementDirect, support the development of management and leadership excellence across the UK. Through in-depth research and policy surveys of its 90,000 individual and 450 corporate members, CMI maintains its position as the premier authority on key management and leadership issues.
- The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) is the world's largest Chartered HR and development professional body, setting global standards for best practice in HR. With over 135,000 members across 120 countries, the CIPD is focused on supporting and developing those responsible for the management and development of people within organisations.
- The Institute of Leadership & Management (ILM) is Europe's leading management organisation. We believe that good leadership and management holds the key to organisational effectiveness and social and economic prosperity. Our fast-growing community of over 35,000 practising leaders and managers gives us a real insight into the issues affecting the management community day-to-day, both in the UK and globally. Each year we help over 92,000 practising and aspiring managers to fulfil their potential and achieve success through a range of flexible leadership and management development solutions. Backed by an in-depth programme of research, ILM operates internationally, improving leadership and management skills, across all sectors, from financial services to the armed forces. www.i-l-m.com